Confused Explorers of California Jaclyn Gee
Dora Beale Polk began her studies in Britain
during World War II, working towards becoming an English teacher. She then moved to California,
where she is continuing her teaching career as a professor of English Emeritus
at California State
University in Long
Beach. As
well as the Island of California, Polk has published other books; her
most recent is Something Must Be Done
(2003), a novel depicting the slums in Wales
during the Great Depression.
In a superstitious and
science-lacking society, the European explorers of the fifteenth century
searched tirelessly for the origin of the Amazon myth, a myth that told of
islands rich in gems, gold, fruitful land, and beautiful women, a myth that
formed the ¡§basic aspiration for mariners.¡¨1 These mariners, starting from the
fifteenth century, have their stories told in The Island of California: A
History of The Myth by Dora Polk.
Explorers aspired to find the famed Amazons, a myth that faded
periodically and swelled back into the forefront of explorers¡¦ minds. This myth created an ongoing search for
the island of California.
In
the first portion of chapters, Polk explains how the Amazon myth was thought to
originate from the Indies, or India,
matching the accounts of travelers who traveled across India
for valuable spices. Because of the
Indies¡¦s
close association with the myth, explorers became consumed with finding a
passage to the Asian continent, and in turn finding the wealthy islands of the
myth. Furthermore, this myth was
embellished and supported by sailors who claimed they glimpsed an island off in
the distance. Polk notes that,
during this era, ¡§scientific thought was just awakening,¡¨ so outrageous claims
of sailors claiming to reach the Indies in a relatively (and unrealistically)
short period of time remained unchallenged.2 Written
accounts confirming the theories, such as the Letter of Prester
John, cited by Polk, were widely circulated, spreading the myth of a large
mass of islands from the explorers¡¦ beliefs to popular opinion. Also, Marco
Polo gave his experiences from encountering ¡§Paradise¡¨
in his account named Book.
Here, the myth was expanded to become Paradise,
or, in other words, the tangible Garden of Eden discussed in the Bible. However, myths began to mingle with
reason as Amerigo Vespucci
explored the Americas
after Columbus¡¦s famed
expedition. Discovering that the Americas
were quite different from descriptions of the Indies, Vespucci concluded that the New World
was a fourth continent, prompting Magellan to carry on his explorations to find
the Strait of Magellan around the southern tip of South
America. The
exploration continued as Vasco Nunez de Balboa reached the Pacific
Ocean and Bachiller Martin Fernandez de Enciso claimed the Pacific coastline for Spain. Then Hernando Cortes followed with his
infamous destruction of the Aztecs and the Mayas; but, drunk with greed, Cortes
continued exploring and conquering natives because of his ¡§conviction about the
existence of the rich, many-thousand isles of Ind¡K[waiting]
to be discovered by a conqueror-hero like himself.¡¨3 A strong believer in the island
myth, Cortes contributed to the myth¡¦s rise through his popularly-known
expeditions in search of the island
of California.
Beginning
in chapter nine, Polk shows how maps drawn in the sixteenth century reinforced
the idea of California¡¦s
insularity. Cartographers pictured
the New World as a thin strip of land, not nearly as
vast as in reality, continuous with Asia and with many
islands clustered around America¡¦s
west coast. These maps led to the
perception of California being an
island. Using these maps to explore
the Pacific coast, Cortes searched in vain for Paradise,
until the Spanish king grew weary of financing worthless expeditions. Soon Ortuna Ximenes took Cortes¡¦s place and
discovered Baja California, an
important enhancement to the island-of-California theory. As a peninsula, Baja appeared to be an
island to the sailors in the Pacific, reviving the myth of the long-sought
Amazons. The vicious natives on the
Baja shores confirmed the myth; they paralleled the impenetrable guardians of Paradise. Sent to explore this region for
confirmation were Marcos de Niza and Francisco
Vasquez de Coronado by Cortes¡¦s enemy, Viceroy
Mendoza. Mendoza and Cortes both
sought control over the famed Paradise, partially
because of its mythical value and partly because of its insularity. The Spanish king had granted Cortes
governorship over all lands he conquered, but the king cheated him out of the governorship. To insure this wouldn¡¦t happen again,
Cortes wanted the security an island would bring him in clearly defining the
borders of his domain. In a last
attempt to make a breakthrough discovery, Cortes sent Francisco de Ulloa to probe the California
gulf for a strait, confirming its insularity. However, Ulloa
was plagued with misfortune and named the last point he rounded Cabo del Engano (Cape of Deceit)
to ¡§symbolize the last straw of the compounded frustrations and disappointments
endured by the crew in this yearlong quest,¡¨ as Polk believes he did.4
These fruitless voyages were repeated numerously before California¡¦s
true geography was officially confirmed.
Though
the treacherous weather experienced by Ulloa seemed
to confirm the theory of Paradise and the obstacles
placed around it, the island theory fell into decline as the Spanish people
began to believe that Baja was a peninsula in Polk¡¦s following chapters. However, Britain
rose to take Spain¡¦s
place, placing all support in Robert Thorne¡¦s theory of a Northwest
Passage going between North America and the
Artic and into the Pacific. An
imaginary strait ¡V The Strait of Anian ¡V would have
made this possible but, because some doubted it, an expedition was first
conducted to see if the strait existed.
This expedition was led by Francis Drake under the Grenville
Plan of 1577, which had Drake navigate through the Strait of
Magellan and sail north.
However, the increased amount of British interest in the Pacific led to
widespread panic by the Spanish. Spain
believed that, as Drake sailed home from the North, the ¡§English ships would
thereafter come sailing down through the gateway of
the [California] gulf to
terrorize the mainland.¡¨5 Simultaneous to Spanish fears of the
English, the theory of California¡¦s insularity was again ignited, as Spain
believed that the English would attack the mainland through the nonexistent,
but perceived, gulf that separated California from the mainland. While this theory rose in
approval, so did Cortes¡¦s theory that the Colorado
River, which dumps into the top of the California
Gulf, was actually the strait
dividing California from the
mainland. Drake desired to confirm Cortes¡¦s theory and, though he failed to verify it, became
so deeply associated with it that eventually the English population credited
him for its creation. The theory of
California¡¦s insularity was again
on the rise.
To counter the growing
threat of Drake, the Spanish King Phillip launched another expedition, this
time of the outer coast of California
to survey the land and test its ability to support settlements. In these final chapters, as Polk
concludes her research, Antonio de Espejo explored
the mainland area of New Mexico
and searched for the strait by land; Francisco Gali
explored the coast and proved its ability to support a colony. However, exploration of the gulf was
more difficult, so the king resorted to enterprises, granting monopolies in
pearl fishing to Hernando de Santotis in return for a
thorough exploration of the gulf. However, as Santotis
began to fail in his expeditions due to bad weather, Sebastian Vizcaino pleaded to take his place, believing that a Strait
of California existed and led to
another ocean (a popular idea at the time). Vizcaino¡¦s
findings bolstered the island myth, except this time it took a new turn: ¡§it
was a realistic, not a mythic, paradise that he described.¡¨6 California became a land of
natural bounties and safe harbors instead of mystic powers, but despite these
findings, the region lay dormant for a number of reasons: Spanish world power
was in decline, foreign threats disappeared, and California
was too large a region to colonize.
This dormancy didn¡¦t last long, though, as Juan de Onate
was sent to explore the mainland of New Mexico. He believed that an east-west river
strait joined with a north-south one, confirming the strait theory and even the
Amazons. The existence of such
straits would make colonization of California
and the mainland much easier, something that Spain
was planning to do. The Protestant
Dutch and English, referred to collectively as Lutherans by Spain,
made them feel threatened, so Spain
wanted to colonize to prevent the Lutherans from invading the mainland and
claiming it for themselves. Tomas
de Cordona explored the gulf in search of a strait
while Onate searched on the mainland. Though they failed at finding it, the
myth continued to rise and was reinforced by Edward Waterhouse¡¦s A
Declaration of the State of the Colony and Affairs in Virginia. This account suggested that the Pacific
and Atlantic oceans were only separated by Virginia¡¦s
land mass and a much thicker Strait
of Anian. Finally, however, Jesuit Father Eusebio Kino, who traveled up the Colorado River
and disproved the island theory through his measurements, challenged these
unrealistic theories of the Amazons, straits, and islands. It took many years for this to replace
the theories that were believed for so long; evidence of the struggle between
the truth and myth is even found in Jonathan Swift¡¦s Gulliver¡¦s Travels,
which satirizes the argument through Brobdingnag, a
land that was either ¡§a great island or continent.¡¨7
But at last, Ferdinand VI in 1747 declared California
connected to the landmass of North America, confirming
its true geography without argument and ending Polk¡¦s interpretation of California¡¦s
history.
While
examining the history of California¡¦s
exploration, Polk extends her research to include more than just historical
facts. Her book is based on the
thesis that ¡§myths start as notions or speculations waiting to be tested, only
to become entrenched and resistant to the onslaughts of empirical and rational disproofs.¡¨8 Her book
intertwines an examination of how popular beliefs, here myths, can be changed,
influenced, destroyed and resurrected.
Because Polk doesn¡¦t rely on history alone for her writing foundation,
she dips into other fields of study ¡V cartography, psychology, geography, and
literature. The Island of
California is sprinkled with a number of maps that bolster her arguments,
as well as quotations from different literary sources to show where her
convictions originate. She examines
the ways that myths and beliefs are spread and how psychological effects can
influence history, in this case the history of California. By moving beyond the facts into deep
analysis, Polk creates a well-rounded and thorough understanding of California¡¦s
early history.
Polk
teaches English at the California State University of Long Beach, proving that
she has a passion for the techniques of writing and for literature. Her appreciation for literature is
easily recognized even without this fact; she cites numerous literary works and
quotes them often in her book, relying on them as a window into popular beliefs
and exploration observations. She notes
that her ¡§book grew out of a larger interest in man¡¦s emerging consciousness
and the history of ideas.¡¨9 The 1990s, the
decade that The Island of California was written, saw an increase in California¡¦s
popularity as the representative of the American dream of riches and
glamour. In her book, Polk shows
how the American dream was embodied in California
even before America
existed through the myths of the Amazons and the explorers who spread
them. Also, as a California
resident, Polk represents ¡§man¡¦s emerging consciousness¡¨ through her own
consciousness of her home state and its origins.
Critical
literary reviewers declare The Island of California a credible and
worthy historical book. Ken Dvorak
in his review believes that Polk ¡§provides a highly effective narrative
discussing the evolution of the island myth¡¨ as she ¡§deftly maneuvers the
reader through an analysis of humankind¡¦s emerging global awareness.¡¨10
Because of Polk¡¦s diversity in her subject matter, she offers a thorough
history of the myth, rather than a review of cold hard facts. She also applies history to the present
growing awareness of the world, showing how history directly relates to current
situations. Also, by saying she
does this ¡§deftly,¡¨ Dvorak suggests that Polk contains the qualities of a
skilled writer. Leslie Ellison
continues this praise in her review, stating that Polk¡¦s content is ¡§[wide]
ranging¡¨ and ¡§her painstaking research [is of] the geography of the mind.¡¨11 Here, Ellison
suggests the same qualities in Polk¡¦s writing that Dvorak does. The critics¡¦ approval is partially from
the diversity of her content ¡V focusing on many ranges of study rather than
facts. Overall, The Island of
California is, as Dvorak puts it, ¡§a welcome addition to the history of California.¡¨
In
The Island of California, Polk supports her arguments well. Not only does she support her
claims with quotations from the explorers¡¦ writings, but she also contains
visuals and maps from the time period.
These quotes and maps support Polk¡¦s words as she weaves through the
history of the popular opinion regarding the myth of California¡¦s
insularity and possibly its association with the Amazons. Also, Polk writes ¡§with the general
reader in mind¡¨ with ¡§chronological narration [selected] as the simplest vehicle.¡¨12 Because she is
writing for the average reader, her claims are supported clearly, concisely,
and logically. Also, she organizes
her book chronologically, making her examination of California¡¦s
discovery easy to follow while she discusses the rise and fall of the
myth. As a teacher of English in a California
State University,
Polk has the techniques of a skilled writer to create such a well-structured
book.
The
exploration of California
depended little on the west¡¦s American counterpart, the east coast. Because explorers knew of the Eastern
North America and of its geography, they were prompted to explore
the West thoroughly to expand their understanding of the continent. Also, the British supported an insularist view of the Americas
and of California ¡V that is, they
believed that North America was a ¡§collection of islands
and wide waterways,¡¨ an idea ¡§championed by the insularists.¡¨13 This view benefited them because
they sought the North-West passage to reach the Pacific Ocean;
if North America were smaller, the passage could be
easily navigated around. But if the
eastern United States
was included in the desperate expeditions to California,
more information might have been acquired on the North-West passage,
or, more accurately, information would have proved the passage unreasonable and
impossible. The vastness of the
eastern United States
was not known, leaving explorers to assume the size of North America
much smaller than its actual size.
California¡¦s
history throughout its exploration set it apart from the rest of America¡¦s
history. The state began as a
region believed to hold mythological riches and wealth, and through time it
maintained that reputation. While
other regions were swiftly explored, claimed, and occupied, California
remained shrouded in the imaginary, mysterious powers of the myths, and housed
the famous Amazon legend. Only California
presented such a continuous frustration that it would take nearly two hundred
years to confirm its geography and colonize its land. The region was also desired more than
any other American region; only its promise of wealth and satisfaction pushed
the weary explorers to continue exploring for centuries. Polk also notes California¡¦s
present value to the rest of the country.
The state now offers its ¡§own native variety and abundance¡¨ to
contribute to its ¡§natural wealth.¡¨14 Polk suggests
that its wealth surpasses other states through its diversity, mostly
agricultural. It also offers a
romantic appeal through the media center of Hollywood
¡V a glamour reminiscent of the 16th century
dreams for gems and gold. Through
these characteristic traits of California,
the state offers the country a unique diversity.
The
island of California,
what Polk has monitored and implied as myth and falsehood, ironically becomes
tangible in Polk¡¦s last, lingering words.
Through plate tectonics, scientists believe that California
will eventually break off to become its own island, as if the myth from the
fifteenth century foreshadowed its future.
Despite its scientific empiricism, this continuing ¡§myth¡¨ of
California¡¦s insularity proves Polk¡¦s entire purpose in following the myth¡¦s
history - that ¡§myths are
ultimately indestructible¡¨ after being ingrained in the human perception of earth.15
Still remaining after six hundred years, the myth will prosper until it
becomes reality.
1. Dora Beale Polk, The Island
of California: A History of the
Myth (Spokane, Washington: Arthur H. Clark Company, 1991) 19.
2. Polk, Dora 23.
3. Polk, Dora 80.
4. Polk, Dora 154.
5. Polk, Dora 221.
6. Polk, Dora 251.
7. Polk, Dora 311.
8. Polk, Dora 14.
9. Polk, Dora 14.
10. Ken Dvorak, ¡§California
Dreams Started Early,¡¨ rev. of The Island
of California: A History of the
Myth, by Dora Beale Polk. Journal of American Culture, 19(2),
159.
11. Leslie Ellison, ¡§The Americas,¡¨
rev. of The Island
of California: A History of the
Myth, by Dora Beale Polk. JSTOR, The Geographical Journal,
Vol. 158, No. 2, (July 1992).
12. Polk, Dora 15.
13. Polk, Dora 185.
14. Polk, Dora 330.
15.Polk,
Dora 332.